How to Re-engage Inactive Subscribers with Your Newsletters

If you aren’t actively re-engaging your audience, you’re slowly losing a significant portion of them. 

Worse, inactive subscribers can hurt your deliverability, making it more likely your emails will land in spam folders.

So, how do you win them back? A re-engagement strategy isn’t just about blasting out another email; it requires a thoughtful approach.

In this blog post, we’ll cover actionable ways to identify, re-engage, and, when necessary, remove inactive subscribers to keep your email list healthy and responsive.

Identify Inactive Subscribers and Understand Why They Went Silent

Before you can bring back lost subscribers, you need to figure out who they are and why they stopped engaging in the first place. 

Not all inactive subscribers are the same, so defining inactivity for your business is crucial.

• Identify inactivity: Set clear criteria—maybe they haven’t opened an email in 60-90 days or have never clicked on anything.
• Segment inactive users: Use email analytics tools to categorize them based on past interactions.
• Investigate disengagement reasons: Some subscribers feel overwhelmed by too many emails, others no longer find the content relevant, and some may not even realize your emails are landing in spam.

Gather insights: Send a survey asking why they stopped engaging or check for deliverability issues.

Craft a Compelling Re-engagement Email

Once you’ve identified inactive subscribers, it’s time to win them back with an irresistible email.

A good re-engagement email should have a subject line that grabs attention, like “We Miss You! Here’s a Gift” or “Still Interested? Let Us Know.” 

Personalization is key—use their first name and reference their past interactions to make the email feel less generic. Beyond just grabbing their attention, you need to offer something valuable. 

This could be an exclusive discount, early access to premium content, or even personalized recommendations based on their previous engagement. 

Keep it short, engaging, and action-driven. Your goal is to remind them why they subscribed in the first place and give them a reason to come back.

Run a Re-engagement Campaign with Multiple Touchpoints

A single email might not do the trick. Instead, consider setting up a re-engagement sequence that gradually rekindles interest. 

Start with a friendly reminder email, letting them know you miss them. Follow up with something of value—maybe a special discount or an exclusive piece of content. 

If there’s still no response, add a sense of urgency, like “This is your last chance to stay subscribed.” Finally, if they remain unresponsive, send a courteous email confirming their removal from your list while offering them one last opportunity to opt back in.

Testing different approaches can improve results. A/B testing subject lines, adjusting send times, and experimenting with different call-to-action buttons will help you see what works best. 

Sometimes, even tweaking the tone—going from formal to casual—can make a difference in engagement.

Experiment with Different Email Formats and Content

If your usual emails aren’t getting responses, it might be time to shake things up. A plain text email, for example, can feel more personal than a highly designed template. 

Storytelling emails—where you share a behind-the-scenes look at your business or a customer success story—can also create a stronger connection.

Adding interactive elements like polls, quizzes, or GIFs can make your emails more engaging and encourage subscribers to take action. 

The key is to stand out in a crowded inbox and make it as easy as possible for people to interact with your content.

Adjust Sending Frequency and Let Subscribers Customize Their Preferences

Not all inactive subscribers want to leave; some just need a different experience. Giving them more control over what they receive can make a huge difference. 

Offer a “lighter subscription” option, where they can choose to get emails less frequently, like a monthly digest instead of weekly updates.

Letting them customize what kind of content they receive—such as promotions, industry news, or personal insights—ensures they only get emails that interest them.

Testing new content formats is another way to keep subscribers engaged. Maybe they prefer video over text or interactive guides instead of standard newsletters. 

The more flexibility you offer, the better chance you have of keeping them engaged long-term.

Know When to Say Goodbye and Clean Your List

If a subscriber still isn’t engaging despite multiple attempts, it’s time to part ways. Keeping inactive users on your list only hurts your email metrics and can impact deliverability. 

Instead of just silently removing them, send a final email letting them know they’ll be unsubscribed soon unless they take action.

• Give them a last chance: Send a “final notice” email with an easy way to opt back in.
• Automate list cleaning: Use email tools to remove inactive subscribers periodically.
• Maintain a quality list: A smaller, engaged list is better than a large, unresponsive one.

A cleaner list improves open rates, boosts conversions, and keeps your sender reputation strong.

Conclusion: It’s About Your Strategy

Re-engaging inactive subscribers isn’t just about sending a single email and hoping for the best. 

It takes a strategic approach—identifying disengaged users, understanding their reasons, and crafting personalized, engaging content that brings them back. 

By implementing these tactics, you’ll improve open rates, increase conversions, and maintain a strong, engaged email list.

FAQ